Not only are they very in-game accurate, they are a great product.
To start, I only have one of my ears pierced, and only for about less than a year.
Because of this, I only use one of the earrings in the pair that was purchased and leave the other in the box. The one earring I DO use, I alcohol wipe and sterilize on the daily to care for my healing earlobe. With the picture I provided, you can hardly tell which one is the one I use daily and as a result, treat more roughly. (It's the bottom one)
5/5 would recommend.
Note: The backing was a little tight when they first arrived (which is a good thing of course), but you can loosen them yourself.